The most telling privacy headline last week didn’t come from Washington or Brussels. It came from city hall. On Thursday, MediaPost reported that NYC bans ‘surveillance pricing’.

Two days earlier, the same outlet reported that the California Privacy Agency fined FedEx nearly $3M. The same week brought a state broadband settlement, two fights over state social media laws, and a stack of rulings and reports on kids and teens.

For years the industry waited for a federal privacy law that would settle the rules in one place. What it’s getting instead is enforcement from every direction at once. That changes who marketers need to watch, and how they should build.

Surveillance pricing went from question to local law

The archive shows how fast this idea moved. In July 2024, AdExchanger reported that the FTC ordered companies to disclose info on “surveillance pricing”. A few weeks later, the trade press was still running explainers on what the term even meant.

A year later it had legislation behind it. In July 2025, MediaPost reported a new bill that would ban ‘surveillance pricing’, and in December a Senate bill that would outlaw ‘surveillance pricing’. Last week the first ban we’ve seen in our coverage arrived, and it came from a city, not Congress.

For marketers this matters beyond retail pricing teams. The same customer data that feeds personalization and audience building can feed pricing. Once a city treats one use as off limits, every use of that data gets a closer look.

States are enforcing, and courts are deciding

California is the obvious model. The CCPA passed in 2018, and by 2020 about one in every 400 stories we collected mentioned the CCPA. In 2019, AdExchanger reported that the privacy advocate behind the CCPA had a new, tougher proposal for the 2020 ballot. That proposal became the CPRA, which created the agency that just fined FedEx. Our coverage peaked as the law was finalized and took effect. The consequences are arriving now, long after the industry stopped paying close attention.

Other states are using the tools they already have. MediaPost reported that T-Mobile settled charges it violated a New York broadband law. And private suits keep coming, even if they don’t all reach a courtroom: an Ace Hardware privacy battle was sent to arbitration.

Kids and teens are where this gets most contested. MediaPost reported that Arkansas is pushing to enforce its social media restrictions and that NetChoice will ask SCOTUS to block Georgia’s social media restrictions. In a separate line of cases, schools can’t revive ‘addiction’ cases against social platforms. The platforms aren’t waiting for the outcome: Meta rolled out global AI age-checks for Instagram teen accounts.

The pressure on advertising to young people isn’t only about data. MediaPost also reported that children and teenagers are hit with thousands of food messages per year. Reports like that tend to show up later in testimony. One of the biggest federal actions on kids’ data in our archive came in 2019, when Google settled with the FTC over a YouTube COPPA violation. Today, more of the action is in statehouses and courtrooms.

Europe adds its own layer

Brussels hasn’t stepped back either. ExchangeWire reported that TikTok’s infinite scroll faces EU regulatory scrutiny, which takes regulation from what data is collected to how a product is designed. VideoWeek noted that IAB Europe laid out its Digital Fairness Act concerns, a sign the industry expects that proposal to touch advertising directly.

Restrictions on what can be advertised are spreading too. MediaPost reported a new coalition pushing fossil-fuel marketing restrictions at COP31, and AdExchanger noted that the Super Bowl’s prediction market ad ban stands. Some of those limits come from regulators and some from the media owners themselves. Either way, the list of things that can’t be targeted, priced or promoted keeps getting longer.

What to do now

This is not legal advice, and the specifics belong with counsel. But some operating habits make every new rule easier to absorb.

Know where your data is used, not just where it’s stored. The NYC ban targets a use. If you can’t say which systems use customer data for pricing, targeting or offers, you can’t respond when one of those uses is restricted.

Make consent and age signals first-class data. Keep them in a CDP or cloud data platform next to the customer profile, so every activation checks them automatically instead of relying on a team to remember.

Plan for many rulebooks. A city, a state, a court and the EU can each set a different line. Build so rules can be applied by geography and audience without rebuilding campaigns.

Watch the courts as closely as the legislatures. Arbitration, Supreme Court petitions and dismissed cases are where many of these rules get their real shape.

The federal law many in the industry hoped for may still come. Until it does, the rules will keep arriving locally, and the companies that know their own data will handle them best.


Every headline in this piece links to the original story. Browse the archive’s coverage of surveillance pricing, the CCPA and COPPA.

Kevin Reynolds is the founder of Advertising Perspectives, MadTech Consulting and data4orce.ai. He is a marketing technology architect and C-level advisor, with a focus on Salesforce and data-driven advertising.