Last week the IAB launched a Trusted Creator Brand Deal Initiative, pitched as building “the infrastructure behind the creator economy’s next phase of growth.” The same day, MediaPost ran a headline that summed up where the market actually is: Creator Buys Surge, Measurement Lags. A second version of the headline sharpened it to measurement remains biggest friction.
Put those two headlines side by side and you have the story of creator marketing right now. The spending has arrived. The industry is building contracts, standards and pricing around it. And the one thing buyers most want, proof of what they got, is still the weakest part.
We’ve seen this sequence before, more than once. Here’s what the archive says about how it tends to play out.
From “influencer” to “creator”
The vocabulary tells part of the story. In 2017, “influencer” came up in about one in every 340 stories we collected at Advertising Perspectives. By 2024 it was closer to one in 50. And somewhere along the way the word itself started to lose ground. In 2018, “influencer” showed up in our headlines more often than “creator.” By 2025, “creator” led by roughly three to one.
That isn’t just a rebrand. An influencer is someone a brand rents reach from. A creator is someone who makes a product: a show, a podcast, a channel with an audience that comes back. Last week’s news was full of the second kind.
Digiday reported on why brands like Anthropologie are commissioning creator-created shows instead of posts, and its Future of TV briefing went inside creator Grace Wells’s 100-hour branded video production process. A hundred hours is not a sponsored post. It’s a production budget. Digiday also covered how a sports betting creator drove 200 million short-form views of his podcast, which is a media company’s distribution strategy run by one person.
And the content is moving to the biggest screen in the house. ExchangeWire’s digest led with Tubi and TikTok teaming up to bring creator content to TV. Once creator video sits next to network shows on a streaming service, it gets bought and judged like TV.
Pricing is moving from reach to results
The second shift is in how creators get paid. Digiday’s headline last week was how performance metrics are rewriting creator rate cards. Platforms are adding shopping and product tools around creators for the same reason: a sale is easier to price than a view.
This is where the archive gets useful, because the industry has walked this road already. In 2018, after a run of stories about fake followers, Kellogg’s told Digiday flatly, “We don’t pay influencers on reach.” Brands that had been burned by inflated follower counts started paying for outcomes they could check.
So performance pricing isn’t new thinking. It was the fix for fake follower counts. What’s new is that it’s becoming the default rate card rather than a defensive clause.
That has a cost the trade press doesn’t always mention. Performance pricing rewards creators whose audiences click and buy, and punishes the ones who build slow brand affinity. Which is why Digiday’s piece on Guinness’ go-slow approach to creators was worth reading alongside the rate card story. Not every brand should be buying creators the way it buys search.
Who gets paid, and who sets the rules
Money is flowing to creators at real scale. ExchangeWire reported that Overwolf paid $400m to creators in 2026, surpassing $1.2bn in lifetime payouts. But the value doesn’t always land where the content was made. VideoWeek’s headline last week: Broadcasters Build Communities Around Their Content, but Third-Parties are Monetising Them. And the events that grew up around creators are wobbling: Digiday wrote that TwitchCon is at a crossroads as creators question its value.
Then there’s trust. MediaPost’s headline Doctors Have Medical Degrees, Health Influencers Have Discount Codes is a reminder that disclosure and credibility are unsolved. In 2016, AdExchanger was warning that when the FTC speaks, brands need to listen, especially on influencer marketing. Performance pricing makes this harder, not easier. A discount code is a great measurement tool and a terrible credential.
That’s the real job for the IAB’s deal standards. Contracts that define deliverables, usage rights, disclosure and reporting are what let a CFO treat creator spend like any other media line.
Measurement is the bottleneck
Measurement tools for creators are much better than they were when this market was called influencer marketing. But the gap in MediaPost’s headline last week hasn’t closed much. Creator content lives on platforms that each report their own numbers, in their own way, and rarely let buyers connect a view to a sale outside the platform.
Short-form clips, a commissioned series on a streaming service and an affiliate link in a podcast are three very different things to measure. Most brands are still trying to compare them on a single dashboard.
What we’d do now
Write the contract before the brief. Use the emerging deal standards as a checklist: deliverables, usage rights, disclosure, what data the creator shares back and when.
Split creators by job. Performance creators get performance pricing. Brand creators get a production budget and a longer horizon. Don’t judge the Guinness approach with a discount-code scorecard.
Bring creator results into your own data. Codes, links and post-campaign reports should land in a CDP or cloud data platform next to every other channel, so creator spend can be compared with something besides itself.
Treat disclosure as a brand safety issue. Especially in health, finance and betting. The regulator has been clear for a long time, and audiences are getting sharper.
Test incrementality, not just attribution. Holdout markets or matched audiences tell you whether the creator moved anything. Platform reports mostly tell you who was standing nearby.
Every headline in this piece links to the original story. Browse the archive’s coverage of creators, influencer marketing and influencer fraud, or read our look at ad fraud’s long history.
Kevin Reynolds is the founder of Advertising Perspectives, MadTech Consulting and data4orce.ai. He is a marketing technology architect and C-level advisor, with a focus on Salesforce and data-driven advertising.