For most of the time we’ve been collecting ad tech news, The Trade Desk was the company that rarely had a bad quarter. Last week it had one.
Digiday reported that, amid a difficult transitional year, The Trade Desk posted a rare quarterly revenue decline. AdExchanger’s headline was more direct: The Trade Desk’s revenue slipped in Q3, and if it wants to grow, it must evolve. MediaPost added that competitive headwinds keep coming for The Trade Desk, and ExchangeWire summed up the week as The Trade Desk revenue falls as buying power shifts.
That last phrase is the one worth spending time on. One soft quarter at one company isn’t a trend. A shift in who controls the buy is, and The Trade Desk is where it shows up first, because it built its business on being the buyer’s independent seat at the table.
How the independent DSP got so big
The archive shows how quickly The Trade Desk went from one demand-side platform among many to the reference point for the whole open internet. In 2017, AdExchanger reported that The Trade Desk passed $1 billion in platform spend as non-display products gained steam. That year it appeared in about one of every 1,700 stories we collected. By 2024 it was about one in every 80.
The company grew by doing two things at once. It sold agencies a buying platform, and it set itself up as the open internet’s answer to the walled gardens. When third-party cookies looked doomed, it led the alternative: in 2020, AdExchanger reported that The Trade Desk and LiveRamp united on identity, with Unified ID 2.0 becoming part of LiveRamp’s ATS. OpenPath, its direct line to publishers, followed. Each move added to the same story: the buyer’s platform, independent of any media owner.
Then came Kokai, its AI-driven buying platform. In 2023, AdExchanger noted that The Trade Desk’s Kokai upgrade takes inspiration from the walled gardens it reviles. That headline aged well. More automation means the platform makes more of the decisions, and buyers have been slow to hand them over.
Three places the buying power went
To Amazon. Amazon has what an independent DSP can’t: its own shopper data, its own inventory and its own streaming video. In 2025, MediaPost reported on the Amazon DSP striking an ad deal with Disney, the kind of premium streaming supply every independent DSP wants access to. Last week, Digiday wrote that Amazon’s auction trial puts agentic advertising’s trust problem in focus. Whatever comes of that, it’s a reminder that the biggest competitor is also a media owner, the very conflict The Trade Desk built its pitch against. We covered the long version of that argument in our piece on walled gardens.
To the supply side. Publishers and SSPs have more leverage than they did. Even The Trade Desk’s own Zoë Mann told Beet.TV that publishers find new leverage as outcomes beat cheap reach. Meanwhile, AdExchanger’s Tuesday roundup asked about PubMatic going all in on agentic buys, and how much power is too much power. When the seller’s platform can run the buy, the buyer’s platform becomes optional.
To agents. Agentic buying lets software negotiate directly between buyers and sellers. We wrote about the mechanics in our piece on agentic advertising. For a DSP, the risk is simple: if an agent can find the inventory, set the price and place the order, the question becomes what the DSP’s fee is paying for.
The fee question was always there
That fee question isn’t new, but last week it was a headline: MediaPost wrote that only programmatic advertising gets away with taking a 55% cut. Shinka’s CEO told Beet.TV that ad tech needs a referee, not another player with a whistle.
Both point at the same thing. The Trade Desk’s original advantage was that it sat on the buyer’s side and didn’t own media. As it adds more of its own products to the supply chain and more automation to the buy, it starts to look like one more player with a whistle. That’s a hard position to defend against Amazon, which doesn’t pretend to be neutral, and against SSPs, which are moving toward the buyer from the other side.
The company’s response, according to Digiday, is that it is eyeing the M&A aisle. Acquisitions can buy capability. They can’t easily buy back the perception of independence, and that perception was the product. None of this tells you where the company goes from here. It does tell you the open internet’s buying model is being renegotiated.
What we’d do now
Know what each layer costs you. Ask every platform in your supply chain for its take rate and what it does for that money. If nobody can show you, that’s your answer.
Don’t rely on one DSP for strategy. Use your DSP for execution, and keep your audience strategy, measurement and first-party data in a CDP or cloud data platform you control. That makes switching, or splitting, a business decision rather than a migration project.
Test the supply side directly. Curated deals and seller-run buys are worth testing against your usual path. Compare outcomes, not CPMs.
Ask every vendor whose side it’s on. Amazon, SSPs and DSPs are all reaching for the same middle. Get each one’s conflicts in writing.
Treat agentic buying as a fee audit. Agents will make it obvious which steps in the chain add value. Start that audit now, before an agent does it for you.
Every headline in this piece links to the original story. Browse the archive’s coverage of The Trade Desk, Amazon DSP and Unified ID 2.0.
Kevin Reynolds is the founder of Advertising Perspectives, MadTech Consulting and data4orce.ai. He is a marketing technology architect and C-level advisor, with a focus on Salesforce and data-driven advertising.